I totally forgot to post this here! Here it is now. Also, it's a kind of finger/hand puppet? Which I made as an assignment for my Children's Theatre course. But I basically made it like a plushie with finger holes, so I figured it was appropriate for this comm.
I think it came out pretty good :D I can make it 'swim', but not as well as I could before I stuffed it; I think I overstuffed it a bit.
And yes - I did use button eyes - regular eyes seemed like they would look kind of creepy? Anyways, here's a quick picture of fishfish on top of my couch with the other plushes :D the only one I didn't make there is the lobster on the far left.